The BMFMREE · est. 2026

Back to the Feature

Roads? Where we’re going, we don’t need roads. We need a movie.

My best friend Jon and I have been texting each other “what should I watch?” since high school. So we fed this thing 1,657 of our own ratings, from my old Jinni account (RIP, 2015) to Jon’s very serious Letterboxd. Set the time circuits, hit 88, and it picks something neither of us has seen. Its full name is the BMFMREE. Its polite name is Back to the Feature.

Like Plex, but ours

Lists

Like the King quest, for directors

The checklists

Everything made by the directors, composers and actors behind the movies you two love. Rate one and it’s ticked off.

From one best friend to the other

Recommendations

So Doc knows what you can watch tonight

My services

Already paid for

On my services

Settings

    A tap on the shoulder

    Notifications

    Jon found them. Doc found the pattern.

    Check my old Jinni stars

    The last 175 ratings in my 2015 Jinni export aren’t like the other 580: only 10s, 8s, 6s and 2s, and seven in ten are perfect tens. That’s where Jon found Highschool of the Dead at five stars. Keep the stars, fix them, or say I never saw it. Jon sees what I decide.

    Loading the pile…

    Checked so far
      For later

      My want-to-see list

      Sort
        Every star, in one place

        My ratings

          The AlmanacEvery rating either of you made on this page, with notes, and your stars ready for Letterboxd
          Doc read every star you two ever gave

          Your taste, decoded

          Warming up the flux capacitor…

          Fresh off the Almanac

          Jon’s latest

          Extra! Extra!

          The weekly recap

          Every week and every month we rate anything, Doc writes it up: who rated what, top marks, the rift, the soulmates and what to watch next. Every old edition stays here.

          All editions
            DestinationHow do you want to feel after?
            PresentHow are you right now?
            Time leftHow long have you got?
            PassengersWho’s watching?
            FormatWhat kind of night?
            FuelWhere can you watch it?
            0MPH

            Pick up to two destinations. Skip anything and we’ll guess.

            Settle it before the trailer ends

            Ask Doc

            Type it the way you’d text Jon. Doc answers from the 1,700 movies you two have actually rated, sorted by era, so “the new X-Men” means something. No internet, no AI, just your own stars.

            Seen it? One tap and it’s in the Almanac

            The 88 MPH Blitz

            Rapid-fire rating for everything you’ve seen and never logged. Tap the stars and the next one rolls in. Every rating is one mile per hour. Hit 88 in one sitting and, well, you know.

            0
            mph this sitting · 88 to time travel
            Stars are ties. This breaks them.

            This or That

            Two movies you both loved enough to give four stars or more. Tap the one you’d rather watch tonight. Every duel moves them up or down your list, and a few minutes of it turns a pile of five-star movies into a real top ten. Then make it a picture and send it.

            Your top 20 right now

              Signed in, every duel saves as you, so your ranking follows you from phone to laptop.

              Bragging rights, now with data

              The Race and the Trophy Case

              Every rating either of you logs this week moves your DeLorean. First to 88 wins the week (the prize is being right). Below it, a trophy for every series and era you finish, and a button that sends you to rate the ones you’re missing.

              Two phones, one pick

              Movie Night

              Each of you taps how you’re doing, on your own phone. When you’re both in, the engine picks one movie for the two of you, and both moods count the same. Same couch or different states, it works either way.

              Travis
              Jon

              On the couch right now

              Now Watching

              The shows we’re actually in the middle of. Bump the season as you go, tap Finished when it’s over, then give it stars in the Almanac. No more “wait, what are you watching?”

              Travis is watching

                Just finished

                  Jon is watching

                    Just finished

                      Rate or skip, one card at a time

                      The Hill Valley Drive-In

                      The all-time greats (the AFI list, the critics’ polls, the ones everybody pretends they’ve seen) plus a few wildcards we think you’ll love. Seen it? Rate it. Want to? Queue it. Not your thing? Skip it forever. Every tap teaches the picker.

                      Loading the reel…

                      Our queue

                      Everything either of us tapped “want to see.” Anything that’s in the picker gets a boost there too.

                        Rank what you watch

                        The Almanac

                        Watched something? Log it here. Half-stars, one line, done. Every rating goes into the next pick: love a movie and its kind of night gets a boost, hate one and the engine backs off. It’s the only sports almanac Biff never got his hands on.

                        Grays Sports AlmanacComplete ratings, 1985–2026 (and counting)
                        Stars (tap the left side of a star for a half, or slide a finger across)
                        Travis—
                        Jon—

                        Checking the Almanac…

                          Take your stars to Letterboxd

                          One file with every movie you’ve rated here, ready for Letterboxd’s importer. Shows stay behind (Letterboxd is films only).

                          Open the importer ↗

                          Twenty years of arguing

                          Where we agree, and where we very much don’t

                          Lining up every film we’ve both rated turned up some things about us. Mostly that we’d both follow Indiana Jones into a snake pit, and that one of us is wrong about Big Fish.

                            Soulmate movies

                            Both of us: four and a half stars or better.

                            The rift

                            Our biggest disagreements. The friendship survived. Barely.

                              Jon’s year-end picksHis favorites of 2022 to 2025, category by category, from his spreadsheet
                              From Jon’s spreadsheet

                              Jon’s year-end picks

                              Every year Jon crowns his favorites in a spreadsheet, category by category. The engine treats a win here as a very strong hint.

                              Under the hood

                              How the flux capacitor works

                              It’s a Jinni tribute

                              Jinni was a movie site I loved from 2012 until it shut down in 2015. Instead of “people who liked this also liked,” it tagged every film by mood, pace and feeling. When it closed, it emailed me all 755 of my ratings. I kept them. Eleven years later, here they are.

                              Every pick is hand-tagged

                              About 230 movies, shows and books, each tagged with how it leaves you feeling, the moods it suits, how intense it is and how much attention it asks. Plus the rest of my Stephen King quest. Anything either of us has already seen is left out, including everything on Jon’s old “Bluffer’s Dozens” spreadsheet (best opening scenes, best single-location movies, best villains).

                              It learns from the Almanac

                              The picker weighs your time, mood and destination against how much each of us would like the pick, so “both of us” nights land in the overlap. Rate what you watch and it adjusts. No AI runs on this page; it’s all right here in your browser.

                              Built by Travis, Jon and Claude. Doc Brown would want you to know that Jon’s Letterboxd has 835 films on it and he gave Madame Web one star. Also: see The Perfect Cream Soda, our last very serious project, and my favorite movies.

                              Jon, this one’s for you

                              Ask Doc for a change

                              Want a new button, a different joke, a movie added or banned forever? Tell Claude. It checks every hour, makes the change if it’s about this page, and emails you back with what it did. Bigger ideas go to Travis first.

                              Or email it straight to

                              What we’ve changed

                                While you’re here

                                One short essay on optimism, purpose, and enough — every Saturday morning.

                                No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.